|
This
eating plan is explained in Eat
Right For Your Type by Peter D'adamo. The basic premise
is that the four blood types (O, A, B, AB) evolved at different
points in history and are thus best suited to the lifestyles prevalent
at those times. The four blood types have varying nutritional &
exercise needs, pre-dispositions to different types of illnesses
and react differently to various foods.
Peter's father (James D'adamo) was a naturopath and clinically
tested this plan for 35 years with excellent results. Peter has
expanded on this work. The book includes detailed lists of which
foods are good for each blood type and which should be avoided,
as well as the scientific basis of the diet and an overview of each
blood types nutritional and exercise needs.
However, it appears the science is not as sound as it first appears.
This review
from the Weston A Price foundation website, goes into it in some
depth.
So much for the science - the real question is, does it work? There
is no doubt at all that different people have different metabolic
needs. Various experts recommend many different eating styles.
Most of them have a lot of merit and work really well - for some
people. Some of them have lots of elements in common, but some of
them are quite contradictory. Differences in metabolic types allow
for people's varied needs and explains anomalies such as :
- why some people thrive on a vegetarian
diet, while others feel lethargic and unwell
- why high protein diets cause some
people to lose weight and some to put it on
- why Ayurvedic medicine says milk is very beneficial (it is for
blood type B), while most people are intolerant of dairy products
But the blood type diet is not the best metabolic diet, as it only
takes one genetic marker into account. True, for some people, especially
O types, it works exceptionally well. But others, especially A types,
often do extremely poorly on it. Maybe this is because O types are
told to eat lots of meat and avoid commercial grains, and A types
are told to eat soy. My personal
opinion is that Bob McFerran's metabolic
diets are the best.
If you do decide to try the blood type diets, remember this is
a starting point, and individuals may be intolerant of something
that otherwise would be beneficial for their blood type. It can
be combined with other plans, eg. Food
combining (for people with digestive problems) or the
Zone (best suited to O types). One O-type ER4YT follower said
"I use ER4YT to determine what to eat, and the Zone to determine
when to eat it".
Peter has a good website
which includes FAQ, recipes, and a bulletin board to allow discussion
between users of the plan. The Community
Foundation for Blood Type Living also has a useful site.
These are valuable resources, but it is important to read the book
first (and of course, find out your blood type). Remember, with
any new eating plan, it may take a few weeks before you start to
see results, so don't be discouraged if a friend gets benefits almost
immediately, but it takes you a bit longer. Also remember, if you
don't get results at all, this may not be the plan for you.
For those who find ER4YT unsuitable, the metabolic
diets are the next step.
The following chart gives an overview of the four blood types :
| Blood
Type : O |
The
Hunter : strong, self reliant, leader |
| STRENGTHS |
WEAKNESSES |
MEDICAL
RISKS |
DIET
PROFILE |
WEIGHT
LOSS KEY |
SUPPLEMENTS |
EXERCISE
REGIME |
| Hardy
digestive tract Strong
immune system
Natural defenses against
infections
System designed for efficient
metabolism and preservation of nutrients |
Intolerant
to new dietary, environment conditions Immune
system can be overactive and attack itself |
Blood
clotting disorders Inflammatory
diseases eg. arthritis
Low thyroid production
Ulcers
Allergies |
High
protein : meat eaters meat, fish, vegetables, fruit
Limited : grains, beans,
legumes |
Avoid
: wheat, corn, navy beans, kidney beans, lentils,
cabbage, brussel sprouts, cauliflower, mustard greens
Aids : kelp, seafood,
salt, liver, red meat, spinach, kale, broccoli |
Vitamin
B Vitamin K
Calcium
Iodine,
Licorice
Kelp |
Intense
physical exercise, such as : aerobics
martial arts
contact sports |
| Blood
Type : A |
The
Cultivator : settled, co-operative, orderly
|
| STRENGTHS |
WEAKNESSES |
MEDICAL
RISKS |
DIET
PROFILE |
WEIGHT
LOSS KEY |
SUPPLEMENTS |
EXERCISE
REGIME |
| Adapts
well to dietary and environmental changes Immune
system preserves and metabolises nutrients more easily |
Sensitive
digestive tract Vulnerable
immune system, open to microbial invasion |
Heart
disease Cancer
Anemia
Liver and gallbladder disorders
Type I diabetes |
Vegetarian
Vegetables, tofu, seafood,
grains, beans, legumes, fruit |
Avoid
: meat, dairy, kidney beans, lima beans, wheat Aids
: vegetable oil, soy foods, vegetables, pineapple |
Vitamin
B12 Folic acid
Vitamin C
Vitamin E
Hawthorn
Echinancea
Quercitin
Milk Thistle |
Calming,
centering exercises eg. Yoga, tai chi |
| Blood
Type : B |
The
Nomad : balanced, flexible, creative |
| STRENGTHS |
WEAKNESSES |
MEDICAL
RISKS |
DIET
PROFILE |
WEIGHT
LOSS KEY |
SUPPLEMENTS |
EXERCISE
REGIME |
| Strong
immune system Versatile
adaptation to dietary and environmental changes
Balanced nervous system |
No
natural weaknesses, but imbalance causes tendency toward
autoimmune breakdowns and rare viruses
|
Type
I diabetes Chronic
fatigue syndrome
Autoimmune disorders - Lou
Gehrig's disease, lupus, multiple sclerosis |
Balanced
omnivore : meat (no chicken) dairy, grains, beans, legumes,
vegetables, fruit |
Avoid
: corn, lentils, peanuts, sesame seeds, buckwheat
Aids : greens, eggs, venison,
liver, licorice, tea |
Magnesium
Licorice
Gingko
Lecithin |
Moderate
physical, with mental balance, such as : hiking, cycling,
tennis, swimming |
| Blood
Type : AB |
The
Enigma : rare, charismatic, mysterious |
| STRENGTHS |
WEAKNESSES |
MEDICAL
RISKS |
DIET
PROFILE |
WEIGHT
LOSS KEY |
SUPPLEMENTS |
EXERCISE
REGIME |
| Designed
for modern conditions Highly
tolerant immune system
Combines benfits of Type
A and Type B |
Sensitive
digestive tract Tendency
for over-tolerant immune system, allowing microbial invasion
Reacts negatively to A-like
and B-like conditions |
Heart
disease Cancer
Anemia |
Mixed
diet in moderation : Meat, seafood, dairy, tofu, beans,
legumes, grains, vegetables, fruit |
Avoid
: red meat, kidney beans, lima beans, seeds, corn, buckwheat
Aids : tofu, seafood, dairy,
greens, kelp, pineapple |
Vitamin
C, hawthorn, echinacea, valerian, quercitin, milk thistle |
Calming,
centering exercises eg. Yoga, tai chi Combined
with : Moderate physical, with mental balance, such as
: hiking, cycling, tennis, swimming |
|