|
I sometimes get people asking me to recommend a good snack bar
or energy bar. There's no easy answer to that one as they are all
processed foods.
In this article, I review the best bars I could find in New Zealand,
plus a selection of the more popular ones. Most of them are gluten
free (GF) bars so that this information is useful to the widest
possible audience. Many bars are worse than this, but this will
give you an idea of how to check whether a bar is worth eating or
not. I haven't included protein bars at this stage, they will be
covered in a separate article.
Even the best of bars is a compromise food at best, for those times
when you need some food in a hurry, and didn't prepare. If you already
know you wouldn't eat any of these, click
here for hints on making a better one yourself.
I've ranked them in two ways. Firstly, by ingredients. Maximum
ranking is 5 stars and points have been taken off for:
- Soy
- Artificial sweeteners (eg sucralose,
aspartame. I have allowed glycerine and xylitol though, as compromise
non-nutritive sweeteners)
- Added sugars (with the exception
of honey, which I've allowed as it is a real food. But don't worry,
the total sugar is addressed in the second section)
- Puffed grains
- Refined flours or starches
- Unhealthy or unspecified vegetable oils
- Common allergens (eg. gluten, peanuts
and milk, though I have allowed whey protein)
Secondly, they're ranked by macronutrient ratio. Most bars are
very low in protein and fat, and very high in carbohydrate. This
might be OK, if you had a small part of the bar, with something
high in fat and protein. But if you're grabbing a bar for a meal
on the run, those ratios will disrupt most people's blood sugar.
Bars get a good score if:
- The protein content is 10% or higher
- The total carbs are 40% or lower
- The total sugars are 20% or lower
(Note that these were calculated on the gms listed on the packaging,
which may have been rounded)
If you are a Carbo type, or a sportsperson with high caloric demand,
or are eating part of a bar with something high in protein or fat,
you may wish to choose based just on the ingredient score, and not
worry about the ratio. If you are a Protein type, it 's expecially
important to pick a high star bar in this category.
I'm looking for a bar that gets a high score in both categories,
so that's how the overall scores are calculated. If your criteria
are different, you may rate them differently overall.
Also note that I'm not having a go at the food manufacturers here.
It's a bit of a catch-22 situation as they have to make what sells,
and a healthy bar isn't usually a popular bar. Many consumers want
cheap and tasty, and don't much care about the ingredients. Or get
fooled by the 97% Fat Free label or the Heart Foundation tick into
buying something full of sugar. One bar that used to be made by
Freedom Foods would have been top of the list, but it didn't sell
and they stopped making it.
Cost and availability are based on what I've found in Kilbirnie,
Wellington. In your area this may be different.
If you want to go straight to your favourite bar, here are the
bars I've reviewed:
| Mrs
May's Almond Crunch (56g)
Mrs May's Cran-Blueberry Crunch (56g)
Cost
and availability: Approx $2.60 from health food shops.
I haven't found them in any supermarkets so far. These are
bags of bite sized nut crunches, and are delicious. These
are just two of he flavours available.
Pros:
- Made
from real food.
- Good
macronutrient ratio
Cons:
- Some
flavours have "natural flavours" added, which
are not necessarily good.
- They're
from Australia, so are abit more expensive than NZ bars.
Summary:
The NEW pick of the bunch! They say one serve is
half a bag, but you could easily eat the whole bag yourself.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Mrs
May's Almond Crunch (56g) |
Yes |
320 |
10g
12.5% |
26g
73% |
18g
22.5%
(3g
7.5% ) |
Cranberries,
Blueberries, Cashews, Almonds, Pistachios, Sesame Seeds, Rice
Malt, Organic Evaporated Cane Juice, Sea Salt, Natural Flavor. |
| Mrs
May's Cran-Blueberry Crunch
(56g) |
Yes |
344 |
10g
11.6%
|
24g
63%
|
18g
20.9%
(4g
9.3% ) |
Almonds,Rice
Malt, Organic Evaporated Cane Juice, Sea Salt |
| Ingredients: |
     |
Ratio:
|
     |
Overall:
|
     |
|
| No-No
Sesahoneyme (75g)
No-No Cashoneyew (75g)
Cost
and availability: Approx $1.90 from health food shops.
I haven't found them in any supermarkets so far. There are
other bars in the range, including a Carob flavoured bar.
They are higher in sugar and carbs and not all of them are
gluten free. But check them out and see if they meet your
requirements.
Pros:
- NZ
made, from real food.
- Reasonably
good macronutrient ratio
Cons:
- Some
people are sensitive to peanuts
Summary:
The pick of the bunch! Half a bar is probably adequate,
but even a whole one shouldn't blow your blood sugar out of
the water. Aug
2007 - still good, but lost the top slot!
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| No-No
Sesahoneyme (75g) |
Yes |
399 |
8.6g
8.6% |
31.9g
72% |
18.28g
18%
(15.3g
15.4% ) |
Coconut,
sesame & sunflower seeds, honey, peanuts,
maize cornflour |
| No-No
Cashoneyew (75g) |
Yes |
400 |
7.8g
7.8% |
31.2g
70% |
20.85g
21%
(15.3g
15.4% ) |
Coconut,
cashews, sunflower seeds, honey, peanuts, maize
cornflour |
| Ingredients: |
    |
Ratio:
|
    |
Overall:
|
    |
|
Naked
Goodness Cashew & Coconut Bites (25g)
& 100% Natural Cashew & Coconut (50g)
Cost
and availability: Bites are around $3.90 for a box
of 8 in the supermarket (so under 50c each). I haven't found
the full sized bars here. Also available in Macadamia and
Apricot, which is ranked a bit lower (see
below).
Pros:
- Comes
in two sizes - for many people the smaller size will be
enough
- Mostly
natural ingredients
- Good
macronutrient ratio
Cons:
- Added
sugar, and added glucose syrup. But at least it's from corn,
so still gluten free. (Note that glucose syrup, even though
derived from corn, is much safer then high fructose corn
syrup. It's the fructose that's most dangerous.)
- Added
sunflower oil
Summary:
Probably the best bar you'd be able to find in a
supermarket, or 24/7 store.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Naked
Goodness Cashew & Coconut Bites (25g) |
Yes |
148 |
3.5g
9% |
11.7g
71% |
7g
19%
(4.4g
12% ) |
Toasted
coconut (22%, sulphite), cashew nuts (22%), sunflower seeds
(21%), sesame seeds (14%), honey (9%), raw sugar,
glucose syrup (from maize), sunflower
oil |
| 100%
Natural Cashew & Coconut (50g) |
Yes |
289 |
6g
8% |
22g
69% |
15g
21%
(10g
14% ) |
| Ingredients: |
    |
Ratio:
|
    |
Overall:
|
    |
|
| Nice
& Natural Apricot Natural Nut Bar (35g)
Cost
& Availability: Approx $3.96 for a box of 6 in
supermarkets, so about 66c each. Comes in other GF flavours
- plain, Chocolate and Yoghurt, which are a little higher
in carbs and sugar, so only get one tick.
Pros:
- Good
ratio with comparatively low sugar content
Cons:
- Some
people are sensitive to peanuts
- Added
glucose syrup. But at least it's from corn, so still gluten
free.
Summary:
A nice tasting, economical bar.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Nice
& Natural Apricot Natural Nut Bar (35g) |
Yes |
163 |
5g
13% |
10.2g 56% |
12.3g
30%
(7.4g
18% ) |
Roasted
peanuts (45%), Dark Chocolate (20%) (Sugar,
Cocoa Liquer, Cocoa butter, emulsifiers (soya lecithin,
476, 492), flavour), sultanas, glucose (from
maize), honey, dried apricots (6%, preservative 220), rice crisps
(rice flour, water), sesame seeds, sunflower
seeds, flavour, citric acid |
| Ingredients: |
   |
Ratio:
|
    |
Overall:
|
   |
|
Australian
Wallaby Cashew & Sesame bar (40g)
Cost
& Availability: Available in health food shops.
Pros:
- Natural
ingredients
- Good
macro nutrient balance
Cons:
- It's
got soy beans in it. Maybe they have been fermented, but
probably not.
Summary:
I personally
wouldn't eat it because of the soy beans, but for others the
good things about it may outweigh that.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Australian
Wallaby Cashew & Sesame bar (40g) |
Yes |
195 |
6g
12% |
13g 60% |
14g
29%
(6.8g
14% ) |
Cashews,
sesame seeds, pepitas, rice extract, rice cereal,
sunflower seeds, soy beans, dietary fibre,
vanilla flavour |
| Ingredients: |
  |
Ratio:
|
     |
Overall:
|
   |
|
Naked
Goodness Macadamia & Apricot Bites (27g)
& 100% Natural Macadamia & Apricot Bars (55g)
Cost
& Availability: Bites are around $3.90 for a
box of 8 in the supermarket (so under 50c each). I haven't
found the full sized bars here. Also available in Cashew and
Apricot, which is ranked a bit higher (see
above).
Pros:
- Comes
in two sizes - for many people the smaller size will be
enough
- Mostly
natural ingredients
Cons:
- Added
sugar, and added glucose syrup. But at least it's from corn,
so still gluten free. (Note that glucose syrup, even though
derived from corn, is much safer then high fructose corn
syrup. It's the fructose that's most dangerous.)
- Added
sunflower oil
Summary:
One of
the best bars you'd be able to find in a supermarket, or 24/7
store.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Naked
Goodness Macadamia & Apricot Bites (27g) |
Yes |
145 |
2.6g
7% |
10g 62%
|
10.8g
30%
(7.5g) |
Sunflower
seeds (19%), dried apricots (15%), macadamia nuts (13%), toasted
coconut (13%, sulphites), honey (10%), raw sugar
(9%), desiccated coconut (7%, sulphites), sesame seeds, glucose
syrup (from maize), buck wheat flour,
rice flour, sunflower oil.
|
| 100% Natural
Macadamia & Apricot Bars (55g) |
Yes |
294 |
5g
7% |
20g 62%
|
22g
30%
(17g) |
| Ingredients: |
    |
Ratio:
|
   |
Overall:
|
   |
|
MegaBurn
Body Boost Bar (60g)
Cost
& Availability: $45 for a box of 10 available
online
Pros:
- Very
good ingredients
- Gluten,
dairy and soy free
Cons:
- It's
let down by the carb and sugar content which is high
Summary:
The ingredients are very good, if you're OK on a
high carb bar. But if you need a higher ratio of fat and protein,
you'd need to have something else with it.
Note that
the other bars in this range all have soy protein in, which
gives them a much lower score.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| MegaBurn
Body Boost bar |
Yes |
227 |
6.5g
11.6% |
6.2g
25% |
32.5g
58%
(16.8g
28%)
|
Rice Malt,
Dried Fruit, Psyllium Husks, Rice Protein, Cashews, Pumpkin
Seeds, Maple Syrup, Multi-strain Lactobascillus culture with
Fructo-Oligiosaccharides, Apple, Kiwi Fruit, Almonds, Tahini,
Rice Bran, Flax Meal, Puffed Rice, Spirulina,
Wheat Grass, Barley Grass, Papaya, Carrot, Mandarin, Fig, Chlorella,
Alfalfa, Beetroot, Orange Flavour( nature identical), Aniseed,
Ginger, Slippery Elm, Cinnamon. |
| Ingredients: |
     |
Ratio:
|
 |
Overall:
|
  |
|
Freedom
Foods Omega Bar (40g)
Cost
& Availability: Approx $9.93 for a box of 6,
in the health food section of the supermarket.
Pros:
- Mostly
good ingredients
- Reasonable
macronutrient ratio
Cons:
- The
added sweetener is fructose which is one of the most dangerous
- Total
carb and sugar content is quite high - more than I'd recommend
for a snack
- Unless
they're stored in the fridge, the flaxseed oil is likely
to go rancid
Summary:
This is a bar I'd maybe eat half of, but a whole
bar is a big sugar hit.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Freedom
Foods Omega bar |
Yes |
494 |
12g
9.7% |
29g
53% |
42g
34%
(21g
17%)
|
Seed mix
(linseeds, sunflower kernels, almonds, macadamia) apple juice
concentrate, honey, fructose, olive oil, flaxseed
oil, puffed amaranth, rice flour, psyllium
husks, omega 3 epa/dha powder 1.24% (from tuna oil), inulin,
lactobacillus, acidophilus me, maize starch, natural vanilla
flavour. |
| Ingredients: |
   |
Ratio:
|
   |
Overall:
|
  |
|
Dr
Mercola's Cocoa Cassava Bar (45g)
Cost
& Availability: These have to be ordered by the
boxful (12) from Dr Mercola's website, and including shipping
come to about $NZ 8 a bar. So a bit expensive for most people!
But I've reviewed them as I know a lot of my readers also
read Dr Mercola, and I thought you might like to know how
his bars stack up.
Pros:
- Mostly
fairly good ingredients
- OK
macronutrient ratio
Cons:
- Labelled
as low carb, but they clearly are not
Summary:
If I lived in the US, I'd maybe keep a box in the
cupboard for when I'm out and about. But although they were
quite nice tasting, overall I didn't think they were that
great, and definitely not worth what it costs to get them
here.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Dr
Mercola's Cocoa Cassava Bar (45g) |
Yes |
190 |
5g
11% |
9g
43% |
23g
48%
(9g
19% )
|
Cassava
Flour, Fruit Juices (Pear, Grape and/or Apple), Natural Rice
Dextrins, Coconut Oil, Dark Chocolate Chips (Cane Sugar,
Chocolate Solids, Cocoabutter, GMO Free Soy Lecithin
[added as an emulsifier], Natural Flavor), Proserum® Whey
Protein, Raw Chia Seeds, Xylitol, Unsweetened Coconut, Dutched
Cocoa Powder, Xanthan, Natural Flavors, Aluminum Free Baking
Powder, Baking Soda, Sea Salt. |
| Ingredients: |
    |
Ratio:
|
  |
Overall:
|
  |
|
Truelife
Fig Bar (75g)
& Truelife Sunny Bar (75g)
Cost
& Availability: Around $1.80 in health food shops.
Or $2.80 for the all-organic version for these two bars. There
are many other flavours, but most of them are even higher
in sugar, and most are not gluten free.
Pros:
Cons:
Summary:
If you have quarter of one as dessert, it's a pretty healthy
one. But as a meal replacement, especially if have the whole
thing, you're likely to feel a bit sick in the short term
and it won't be good for your blood sugar.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Truelife
Fig Bar (75g) |
Yes |
265 |
4.89g
7% |
11.17g
38% |
36.52g
55%
(33.71g
51% ) |
Figs, sultanas,
coconut, sunflower seeds |
| Truelife
Sunny Bar (75g) |
Yes |
271 |
5.82g
8.6% |
10.29g
34% |
38.82g
57%
(35.49g
52% ) |
Sultanas,
dates, sunflower seeds, apricots, hazelnuts, pumpkin seeds,
coconut |
| Ingredients: |
     |
Ratio:
|
- |
Overall:
|
 |
|
Layleys
Apricot & Cashew Bar (50g)
Cost
& Availability: Used to be available in health
food shops, but can't find in my area at present. Ask in your
local shop.
Pros:
Cons:
Summary:
As with the Truelife bars,
if you have quarter of one as dessert, it's a pretty healthy
one. But as a meal replacement, especially if have the whole
thing, you're likely to feel a bit sick in the short term
and it won't be good for your blood sugar.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Layleys
Apricot & Cashew Bar (50g) |
Yes |
189 |
2g
5% |
9.35g 45% |
24.05g
51%
(23.2g
49% ) |
Dates,
Coconut, Dried Apricots (12%) (contain preservative (220)),
Sultanas, Cashew Nut Pieces (2.5%). |
| Ingredients: |
|
Ratio:
|
- |
Overall:
|
|
|
Annies
All Fruit Rollups, Wriggles and bars
Cost
& Availability: Widely available in supermarkets
and health food shops.
Pros:
- NZ
made, from real food.
- Most
bars are pure fruit with nothing added.
Cons:
Summary:
Suitable to replace a piece of fresh fruit, as part
of a balanced meal or snack. But as with fresh fruit, I don't
recommend eating one on it's own. And remember that dried
fruit is more concentrated than fresh, so eat a smaller portion.
Fibre Fruits are not recommended as they include soy.
Note:
These comments only apply to Annies brand,
which are pure. Other brands (eg. Uncle Toby's) have other
ingredients such as wheat derivatives and vegetable oils and
should be totally avoided.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Annies
fruit rollups and wriggles |
Yes |
|
|
|
100% |
Differs
by flavour, but usually pure fruit with no additives. Some include
FOS. Avoid those with soy. |
| Ingredients: |
|
Ratio:
|
- |
Overall:
|
|
|
Sunshine
Organic Treats Berry Bar (75g)
Cost
& Availability: Available in health food shops
at around $4.95 for a box with 2 bars. There are other gluten
free treats in the range, including the Smart One bar which
is similar to this one, and other cakes and biscuits.
Pros:
Cons:
Summary:
As with the Truelife bars,
if you have quarter of one as dessert, it's a pretty healthy
one. But as a meal replacement, especially if have the whole
thing, you're likely to feel a bit sick in the short term
and it won't be good for your blood sugar.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Sunshine
Organic Treats Berry bar |
Yes |
361 |
4.4g
4.9% |
21.8g
54.4% |
35.5g
39.4%
(21.6g
24%) |
Brown rice
flour, free range eggs, coconut, orange juice, honey, palm shortening,
tapioca, sesame seeds, dried fruit (apple, boysenberry, plums),
dairy free chocolate (sugar, vegetable
fat, cocoa powder, emulsifier, flavour). |
| Ingredients: |
|
Ratio:
|
|
Overall:
|
|
|
One
Square Meal (1 bar, 1/2 serve, 87g)
Cost
& Availability: Approx $3.70 for a pack of 2
in the supermarket, approx $4 in dairy or service station.
(Note that the two bars are considered to be the equivalent
of a meal. For a snack, one would be ample, and that's what
is in the table.)
Pros:
- Mostly
fairly natural ingredients
- OK
fats
- Not
high in sweeteners
Cons:
- Includes
soy protein
- Isn't
gluten free
- Low
in protein, high in carbs
Summary:
In truth, this isn't the worst of the bars by a long
shot. Most are much more unhealthy. But this one is worth
mentioning as it's promoted as being so healthy that you could
use two bars to replace a meal, and you'd be covering all
your nutritional bases. But look at the sugar content. This
means two bars have 30g, which means they're saying 90g of
sugar a day is OK. Not in my book it isn't!
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| One
Square Meal (1 bar, from pack of 2) 87g |
No |
347 |
8.4g
10% |
11.6g
30% |
45.1g
52%
(15g
17% ) |
Rolled
oats, Dried apricots 12% (with antioxidant (220)),
Manuka honey 11%, Vegetable oil (rice bran oil, palm oil, palm
kernel oil), Maltodextrin, Isolated
soy protein (non GM), Wheat flakes,
Humectant (glycerine), Raisins, Maize starch, Rice flour, Vegetable
gum (Acacia gum), Natural flavour, Salt, Vitamins & Minerals
(Calcium, Vitamin C, Zinc, Magnesium, Vitamin A, Vitamin D,
Niacin, Vitamin B2, Folate, Iodine), Malted barley extract,
Emulsifier (soy lecithin), Natural colour (caramel III). |
| Ingredients: |
  |
Ratio:
|
  |
Overall:
|
 |
|
Freedom
Foods Muesli Breakfast Bar (35g)
Cost
& Availability: Approx $7.30 for a box of 6,
in the health food section of the supermarket.
Pros:
- Gluten
free
- Fairly
good ingredients
Cons:
Summary:
Coming
in at nearly 60g of carbs, I wouldn't recommend this to anyone.
For people with weight or health problems, 70-80g of carbs
might be their upper limit for the entire day!
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Freedom
Foods Muesli Breakfast Bar (35g) |
Yes |
420 |
8.1g
7.7% |
15.9g
34% |
56.9g
54%
(33.9g
32%) |
Fruit
juice concentrate (pear & apple), sultanas, puffed
rice, sunflower seeds, coconut (preservative 220),
rice bran (rice flour, rice bran, prune juice concentrate),
rice flakes with psyllium (rice flour, maize flour, psyllium,
maltodextrin (corn), apple juice concentrate,
salt, vitamins (niacin, thiamin, folate), mineral (iron), linseed,
inulin, dried appricot (preservative 220), psyllium husks, sesame
seeds, sliced almonds, dried apple, corn starch, natural flavour. |
| Ingredients: |
    |
Ratio:
|
- |
Overall:
|
 |
|
Orgran
Fruit Bar (50g)
Cost
& Availability: Approx $2.80 in health food shops.
Pros:
Cons:
- High
in carbs and sugar
- Added
fructose
- Dangerously
low in fat
- The
small amount of fat present is canola oil
Summary:
They've
fallen into the trap of thinking low fat is healthy, and the
lower the better. We know better - fat keeps your blood sugar
stable, and helps build your cells. It probably tastes nice
if you want to eat it as cake. But it's not a nourishing snack
in any way.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Orgran
Fruit Bar (50g) |
Yes |
161 |
2.2g
5.5% |
1g
5.6% |
30.7g
76%
(21.5g
53.4%)
|
Sultanas,
dates, milled chick peas, milled corn, tapioca, brown rice syrup,
currants, blueberries, fruit concentrate, inulin, fructose,
canola oil, milled rice, natural flavour, sodium
bicarbonate |
| Ingredients: |
    |
Ratio:
|
- |
Overall:
|
 |
|
Cookie
Time Bumper Bar (80g)
Cost
& Availability: About $3.60 for a box of 3 in
the supermarket. Also available singly in service stations.
Come in 3 flavours.
Pros:
- High
in butter, which is good, and unusual in baked snacks these
days
- Reasonably
natural ingredients
Cons:
- They
don't say what the vegetable oil is, so it could be good
(coconut or palm) or bad (canola)
Summary:
If you're on holiday and pull into a service station,
this or a One Square Meal might look like the healthiest choices
available. Admittedly, they are tasty. But if you can find
a bag of nuts and brush the excess salt off, that would be
better.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Cookie
Time Bumper Bar (80g) |
No |
349 |
4.8g
5.5% |
19.8g
51% |
38g
43.6%
(22.8g
26%)
|
Rolled
oats, Butter, Chocolate 15%* (sugar, cocoa
mass, milk solids, cocoa butter, emulsifiers (soya lecithin,
476), malted barley syrup, flavour), Dried apricots 13%*, Brown
sugar, Wholewheat flour, Desiccated coconut, Golden syrup, Vegetable
oil, Wheat bran, Malted barley extract, Sunflower &
sesame seeds, Honey, Salt, Natural flavour, Antioxidant (220).
May contain traces of nuts. |
| Ingredients: |
  |
Ratio:
|
 |
Overall:
|
  |
|
Tasti
Snak Logs (40g)
Cost
& Availability: Around $3.50 for a box of 6 in
the supermarket.
Pros:
- Ratio
isn't as bad as many others
Cons:
- Contains
margarine
- Peanuts
are a common allergen
- Also
contains casein and gluten
- Apple
juice is commonly perceived as healthy, but is high in fructose
- Includes
colour which most of the others don't
Summary:
Nothing
to recommend it. Avoid.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Tasti Snak
Logs (40g) |
No |
178 |
5.4g
12% |
8.3g
42% |
19.3g
43%
(11.2g
25%)
|
Roasted
peanuts, sugar, non fat milk powder, rolled
oats, honey, oat bran, dried apricots (7.5%), margarine
(vegetable oils, salt, emulsifiers (471, soy lecithin), colour
(160a)), sunflower seeds, sesame seeds, glucose,
apple juice concentrate, wheatgerm, flavours. |
| Ingredients: |
  |
Ratio:
|
 |
Overall:
|
  |
|
Mother
Earth Soft and Chewy Berry Choc (32.5g)
Cost
& Availability: Around $4.30 for 8 in the supermarket.
Pros:
- Reasonably
natural ingredients
Cons:
- Very
low in protein
- Doesn't
specify the vegetable oil
- Lots
of different types of added sugars
Summary:
When a bar has only one very weak "pro",and
many "cons", what else can I say except don't eat
it?
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Mother
Earth Soft and Chewy Berry Choc |
No |
129 |
1.5g
4.7% |
4.5g
31.4% |
21.2g
65.7%
(9.7g
30%)
|
Cereals
(36%) (rolled oats, wheat flakes, rice cereal (rice flour, sugar,
salt, emulsifier (471)), glucose syrup, dark
compounded chocolate (15%) (sugar, vegetable
oil, cocoa powder, milk solids, emulsifiers (492, soy
lecithin, 476), salt, flavour), raspberry juice (5%), vegetable
oil (non trans, contains natural antioxidant (306)),brown
sugar, sultanas (4%), dessicated coconut, new zealand
honey, cranberry pieces (2%) (cranberries, sugar,
sunflower oil), blueberries (1%), food acid (citric), emulsifier
(soy lecithin), natural flavour. |
| Ingredients: |
  |
Ratio:
|
- |
Overall:
|
   |
|
Uncle
Toby Chewy bars (Berry)
Cost
& Availability: Around $3.20 for 8 in the supermarket.
Pros:
Cons:
- Hydrogenated
vegetable oil
- Contains
casein and gluten
- Lots
of added sugars
Summary:
It's got
all the bad stuff. Avoid.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Uncle Toby
Chewy bars (Berry) |
No |
136 |
2.1g
6.2% |
4.3g
28.4% |
21.6g
63.5%
(11.6g
34%)
|
Cereals
(rolled oats, wheat), glucose, compound chocolate
(sugar, hydrogenated vege oil,
milk solids, cocoa powder, Emulsifier (soy lecithin, 492), salt,
flavour), sugar, puffed rice
(rice flour, sugar, rice bran, colour, emulsifier),
vegetable oil, flavoured fruit grains (raspberry
puree, wheat fibre), honey, milk solids, humectants (420, 422),
coconut, treacle, salt, emulsifiers, food acid (330), flavour. |
| Ingredients: |
  |
Ratio:
|
- |
Overall:
|
   |
|
Powerbar
Pria (28g)
Cost
& Availability: Approx $1.99 in the health food
section of the supermarket.
Pros:
Cons:
- Contains
soy
- Low
fat
- High
in refined carbs
Summary:
This is made pretty much entirely from soy and refined
carbs. Adding some vitamins and minerals doesn't make it any
better. Eat some real food instead, and avoid these things
unless very desperate.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Powerbar
Pria (28g) |
No |
118 |
5.3g
18% |
3g
22.9% |
15.7g
53.2%
(8.2g
27.8%)
|
Rice
syrup, milk chocolate coating (27%) (sugar,
cocoa butter, milk solids, cocoa solids, emulsifiers (soy lecithin,
492,476), flavour), soy flour (colour (E150d)),
soy protein nuggets (soy protein isolate, rice
flour), rice crisps ( rice flour, tapioca starch, sugar,
malt powder (from barley), salt), humectant
(422), soy protein isolate, rice flour, flavours,
minerals, maltodextrin, vitamins. |
| Ingredients: |
 |
Ratio:
|
 |
Overall:
|
   |
|
Zone
Perfect Orange Cranberry Crunch (50g)
Cost
& Availability: Approx $3.99 in the supermarket.
Comes in 13 different flavours.
Pros:
- It's
a Zone bar, so OK macronutrients ratio
- Gluten
free
Cons:
- Contains
soy and canola oil
- Contains
fructose, one of the most dangerous sugars
- High
in refined carbs
Summary:
They're probably no worse than many others, but they're
not real food. Don't eat them unless you're desperate for
fuel and the only alternative is a Body For
Life bar, and even then starvation is always an option.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Zone Perfect
(50g) |
Yes |
210 |
15g
28.6% |
7g
30% |
22g
41.9%
(15g
28.6%)
|
Soy Protein
Nuggets (Isolated Soy Protein, Tapioca Starch,
Rice Flour, Malt, Salt), Yogurt Coating (Sugar,
Palm Kernel Oil, Nonfat Dry Milk Solids, Yogurt Powder [Cultured
Whey Protein Concentrate, Cultured Skim Milk, Yogurt Culture],
Soy Lecithin, Salt, Natural Flavor), Corn Syrup,
Milk Protein Isolate, Dried Cranberries (Cranberries, Sugar,
Sunflower Oil), Fructose, Canola Oil,
Palm Oil, Glycerine, Water, Natural Flavors. |
| Ingredients:
|
 |
Ratio:
|
  |
Overall:
|
   |
|
Body
for Life bars
Cost
& Availability: About $3.29 in supermarkets.
Lots of flavours available.
Pros:
- Gluten
free
- Reasonable
macronutrient balance, aimed at Zone ratios
Cons:
- Soy
protein
- Lots
of fructose
- Artificial
sweetener (sucralose)
- Artificial
flavourings
Summary:
Body For Life is quite a popular regime still, and
people are out there eating these bars, thinking they're good
for you. They're not, they're appalling.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Body
for life |
Yes |
200 |
15g
30% |
7g
32% |
21g
42%
(10g
20% ) |
Protein
Blend (soy protein isolate, casein, hydrolyzed
whey protein, whey protein isolate, calcium caseinate), high
fructose corn syrup, partially hydrogenated
vegetable oil (palm oil), sugar, invert
sugar, fructose, cocoa, tapioca starch,
modified corn starch, non fat milk,
vitamin & mineral blend, milk protein concentrate, soy lecithin,
cocoa butter, natural and artificial flavor,
caramel, unsweetened chocolate, salt, calcium carbonate, maltodextrin
and sucralose (splenda brand). |
| Ingredients: |
- |
Ratio:
|
  |
Overall:
|
   |
|
Healtheries
Simple Apricot & Yoghurt bar
Cost
& Availability: About $2.79. A fairly new bar,
so not widely available yet. But expect them to see with the
other Simple products soon. Also
available in Berry & Yoghurt and Chocolate
flavour. The Berry and Yoghurt gets even less stars as it
also has added sucralose (total score 4 x's!).
Pros:
- Gluten
free
- Better
macronutrient ratio than some others
Cons:
- Contains
soy protein
- Contains
fructose
- Contains
unspecified vegetable fats
Summary:
If you're gluten intolerant, sometimes you find yourself in
a situation where your choices are to eat gluten or gnaw your
arm off. In that situation, these might be better than losing
an arm....Otherwise avoid.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Healtheries
Simple Apricot & Yoghurt |
Yes |
176 |
7.2g
16% |
4.5g
23% |
22.5g
51%
(12.3g
28%) |
Healtheries
protein blend (17%) (soy protein nuggets (isolated soy
protein, tapioca starch, salt), whey protein concentrate),
dried diced apricot (14%) (apricots, rice flour, preservatives
[220]), glucose syrup (maize), fructose,
yoghurt compound (sugar, vegetable fat, skim
yoghurt powder, whey powder, emulsifiers [soy lecithin,
492], food acid [330]), puffed rice, shortening
(vegetable fats, antioxidant [307]), polydextrose,
rice bran (rice flour, rice bran, prune juice concentrate),
tapioca dextrin, maltodextrin (maize), glycerine,
mineral salt (578), flavour, emulsifier (soy lecithin),
vegetable gum (414), food acid (330). |
| Ingredients: |
 |
Ratio:
|
 |
Overall:
|
   |
|
Vogels
Scroggin Clusters (40g)
Cost
& Availability: Around $4.99 for 6 in the supermarket.
Pros:
Cons:
- High
allergy potential
- Margarine
- Colour
- Sugars
Summary:
The original Vogels was the first whole grain bread in NZ,
and it's still the best of the gluten breads. So it's very
disappointing to see that these clusters are not in the same
league - and in fact are the very opposite. There
are other bars available that are this bad,
or maybe a tad worse, like Milk & Cereal bars, or Milo
bars, but at least those ones you can tell at a glance are
not going to be nutritious.
|
| |
GF? |
Calories |
Protein
|
Fat
|
Carbs
(Sugars) |
Ingredients:
|
| Vogels
Scroggin Clusters (40g) |
No |
172 |
3.3g
7.7% |
6.5g
34% |
22.9g
53.3%
(11.9g
27.7%)
|
Wholegrain
Oats (26%), Sweetened Condensed Milk (Milk,
Sugar), Dried Apricots (11%) (Apricots, Rice Flour, Preservative
(220* Sulphite)), Margarine (Vegetable Oil,
Salt, (Emulsifiers (322 (Soy), 471), Colour (160a),
Flavour)), Dextrose Monohydrate, Wheat Flour,
Brown Sugar, Currants, Inulin (from Chicory),
Peanuts (4%), Dessicated Coconut (Preservative 220* Sulphite),
Linseeds, Vitamins (Vitamin E, Folate). |
| Ingredients: |
  |
Ratio:
|
- |
Overall:
|
   |
|
|